We can never emphasize enough, however, the dangers that lurk in the
world's most populous country -- the nasty traits of some Chinese
businesses that make us fear and loathe them.
An emerging giant
There are nearly 2,000
public companies in China. About 450 are listed in the U.S., with that
number growing all the time. And many of them are future multibaggers
that will make their shareholders rich. Look around and you'll find
businesses such as Fuqi International (Nasdaq: FUQI) and Yongye International (Nasdaq: YONG), which have more than doubled in just the past six months.
But we can't pretend these types of winners are easy to find. If you
don't know the lay of the land -- the ins and outs of Chinese political
structure -- you could quite literally lose a fortune.
Here are just three of the problems to be on the lookout for:
1. Hard-to-decipher financials. The Economist magazine sums it up better than I can:
The financial results of companies that global
investors wish to buy into can be as unintelligible as the dialect
spoken in the company town. It is said (with apparent sincerity) that
some Chinese firms keep several sets of books -- one for the
government, one for company records, one for foreigners and one to
report what is actually going on.
In fairness, this was written a couple of years ago and Chinese
financials are a bit easier to understand now. And there's no doubt
that American companies also do not make available the books we'd really like to see. And the ones we can see aren't necessarily easy to decipher -- especially financials ranging from Freddie Mac (NYSE: FRE) to PNC Financial Services (NYSE: PNC).
But there's little question that we simply can't get the same
lucidity and transparency from Chinese companies that we do from
domestic firms.
2. Questionable quality of earnings. Quality of
earnings refers to the extent to which financial reporting can be
trusted. The more conservative management is with its assumptions, the
better we feel about the numbers it reports.
A 2008 Barron's article relayed a pretty sobering study
from RateFinancials, an independent firm that rates financial reports.
Looking at the five largest recent Chinese IPOs -- including LDK Solar and Yingli Green Energy
-- RateFinancials found problems with "big increases in receivables,
negative operating and free-cash flows, significant amounts of deferred
revenues, major prepayments, and sizable long-term commitments to
suppliers."
3. Poor corporate governance. China is
"perceived to routinely engage in bribery when doing business abroad,"
according to Transparency International. And in TI's 2008 corruption
report, the country falls well below any comfortable level, ranking
72nd.
That doesn't mean every Chinese company is dicey, of course, but
investors must be on guard. So while you can check Yahoo! Finance and
see that U.S.-based Apple (Nasdaq: AAPL),
for example, has an above-average corporate governance rating in the
technology hardware sector, such easy tools don't exist for Chinese
companies.
To sum it up, our Global Gains team warns that
"Shareholders of Chinese companies should know that there is no real
apparatus by which their interests are protected and that they are
essentially betting on being on the same side as management and the
majority shareholders -- who as often as not are branches of the
government, the military, and/or the Communist Party."
And yet ...
Still, China's vast potential cannot be ignored, and investing indirectly through multinationals like Research In Motion (Nasdaq: RIMM) and Oracle (Nasdaq: ORCL)
won't cut it. China is a small part of these companies' businesses; to
realize the greatest potential from China's growth, you'll need to look
to the domestic companies.
We recommend some China exposure as a part of any balanced
portfolio. That's why we travel to the country yearly, and are recently
back from meeting with several companies and some prominent investors.
These meetings -- the ability to sit at the same table as management
and see the business operations with our own eyes -- allow us to
separate the good from the bad, and the quality from the corrupt. (You
can see all of our notes and stock recommendations with a free trial.)
Uncovering a double
In 2008, China Fire & Security Group
seemed to have it all. Revenue had doubled in two years, the country's
market for fire safety products was huge, and several high-profile
industrial accidents had pressured the government to crack down on
safety violators. To top it off, the government enlisted China Fire
itself to help write safety legislation. Talk about the fox guarding
the henhouse!
But there was a hitch: The website ShareSleuth.com had blasted China
Fire for some less-than-stellar corporate structure and ownership
issues, and the share price had cratered 60%.
We were fortunate, however, that our Global Gains analysts
had actually visited the China Fire headquarters, touring the factory
and chatting in detail with management. They were convinced the company
was working earnestly to address the issues, and that the beaten-down
stock price was a real bargain rather than a harbinger of further
deterioration. They recommended the stock in May 2008, and it more than
doubled before it was sold for valuation reasons.
© 2009 UCLICK, L.L.C.
Post new comment